“When faced with malicious damage to your property, having an experienced loss assessor by your side can mean the difference between settling for less and receiving what you’re truly entitled to.” – Trevor Kelly, Director at Insurance Claim Solutions (ICS)
Table of Contents
Understanding Malicious Damage Insurance Claims
Malicious damage to property can be devastating. Whether it’s vandalism, break-ins, or deliberate destruction, the aftermath leaves property owners dealing with both physical damage and emotional distress. According to the Central Bank of Ireland’s 2023 Insurance Industry Report malicious damage claims account for approximately 11% of all property insurance claims filed annually, with an average settlement value of €8,600.
When your home or business suffers malicious damage, navigating the insurance claim process becomes another challenge during an already difficult time. This is where a professional loss assessor steps in.
What Exactly Is a Loss Assessor?
A loss assessor is an independent professional who represents you—the policyholder—throughout the insurance claim process. Unlike a loss adjuster who works for the insurance company, a loss assessor advocates solely for your interests.
It’s important to understand this distinction. The loss adjuster sent by your insurer aims to minimize the claim settlement, while a loss assessor works to ensure you receive a fair settlement that covers the full extent of the damage caused.
How Loss Assessors Differ from Loss Adjusters
Many people confuse loss assessors with loss adjusters, but they serve fundamentally different roles:
Loss AssessorLoss AdjusterWorks for you, the policyholderWorks for the insurance companyAims to maximize your claimAims to minimize the claim payoutYou pay their fee (often a percentage of the final settlement)Paid by the insurance companyOptional to hireAppointed by the insurer automatically
The Rising Problem of Malicious Damage in Ireland
Malicious damage claims have increased by 17% across Ireland over the past three years, according to the Irish Insurance Federation’s Property Claims Report 2023. Dublin, Cork, and Limerick have seen the highest rates, with business properties particularly vulnerable.
According to the Insurance Information Bureau, malicious damage often occurs alongside theft, with approximately 65% of burglary insurance claims including an element of malicious damage. This combination creates complex claims that require expert handling.
When Should You Appoint a Loss Assessor for Malicious Damage?
Significant Damage to Your Property
When malicious damage is extensive or affects structural elements of your property, the claim complexity increases substantially. Insurance companies may dispute certain aspects of repair or replacement costs. A professional loss assessor from ICS can conduct a thorough assessment using quantity surveying principles to document the full extent of the damage caused.
Theft and Malicious Damage Combined
When burglary or theft occurs alongside malicious damage, claims become particularly challenging. Thieves often cause unnecessary damage while searching for valuables or during forced entry. Your insurance policy might treat theft and malicious damage differently, requiring expert knowledge of insurance policies to maximize your claim.
“Insurance policies are designed with specific exclusions and limitations,” explains Trevor Kelly. “Without proper expertise, policyholders often miss claiming for items they’re entitled to, especially when dealing with combined theft and malicious damage claims.”
Business Interruption Concerns
For commercial policyholders, malicious damage can lead to significant business interruption. Beyond repairing physical damage, you may be entitled to compensation for lost income. ICS has helped numerous businesses recover not just property damage costs but also consequential losses that many business owners don’t realize they can claim.
The Claim Process for Malicious Damage: Where Problems Arise
The insurance claim process for malicious damage involves several stages where having a loss assessor proves invaluable:
Initial Documentation and Police Report
Malicious damage claims require a crime reference number from local authorities. Insurance companies scrutinize these claims carefully to prevent fraud, often resulting in excessive questioning that can feel accusatory to genuine claimants.
Assessment of Damage
Insurers frequently underestimate the extent of malicious damage, particularly “consequential damage” that isn’t immediately obvious. For example, broken windows may lead to water damage that appears days later. Loss assessors identify these secondary issues that insurers might overlook.
Policy Interpretation
Insurance policies contain specific clauses regarding malicious damage, vandalism, and theft. Common exclusions often include damage caused by paying guests, tenants, or family members; gradual deterioration misrepresented as sudden damage; and lack of sufficient evidence of forced entry. Without expert understanding of the complexities of insurance policies, you might not claim everything you’re entitled to receive.
Negotiation with Insurers
Perhaps the most challenging aspect is negotiating with the insurance company to ensure proper settlement. Insurers often propose quick settlements that don’t fully cover replacement costs or repairs to pre-incident standards.
How a Loss Assessor Can Help with Malicious Damage Claims
Expert Assessment of Damage
ICS loss assessors have backgrounds in construction, quantity surveying, and property valuation. This expertise allows them to document damage comprehensively, often identifying issues that wouldn’t be apparent to the average property owner or even to loss adjusters.
“Our team approaches each property with the eye of experienced builders and surveyors,” says Trevor Kelly. “We recently handled a malicious damage claim where we identified structural weakening that wouldn’t have been visible without removing damaged wall coverings. This increased the claim value by €14,000.”
Managing the Claim Process from Start to Finish
Managing an insurance claim can be time-consuming and stressful. ICS takes over the entire claim, handling all communication with insurers, documenting damage, obtaining repair quotes, and negotiating settlements. This allows you to focus on returning to normal life while we handle the claim effectively.
Ensuring Policy Compliance
Loss assessors understand what documentation insurers require and how to present it properly. This prevents delays caused by incomplete information and ensures all claim aspects comply with policy terms. Your claim moves forward efficiently when properly managed.
Maximizing Your Settlement
Perhaps most importantly, loss assessors know how to value claims correctly. According to industry data published in the Insurance Journal’s 2023 Claims Analysis (insurancejournal.ie/research), policyholders who use loss assessors receive settlements averaging 30% higher than those who handle claims themselves.
Real Case Study: Malicious Damage to a Dublin Retail Store
A Dublin retailer experienced significant malicious damage during a break-in. Initial assessment by the insurer’s loss adjuster estimated repairs at €22,000. After appointing ICS as their loss assessor, the claim settlement reached €37,400.
The difference? The ICS team identified:
- Structural damage that wasn’t immediately apparent
- Security upgrades necessitated by the break-in
- Business interruption losses during repairs
- Inventory damage beyond the obvious theft
The Loss Assessor Appointment Process for Malicious Damage Claims
When to Contact a Loss Assessor
Ideally, contact a loss assessor immediately after discovering malicious damage to your property, even before contacting your insurance company. This ensures proper documentation from the start. However, ICS can assist at any stage of the claim process.
What to Expect
Once appointed, ICS will:
- Conduct a thorough inspection of all damage
- Review your insurance policy to identify all potential claim areas
- Document everything with photographs, videos, and expert assessments
- Prepare and submit your claim with supporting evidence
- Negotiate with the insurer’s loss adjuster
- Handle all communications, allowing you to focus on recovery
- Ensure you receive the settlement you deserve
Cost Considerations
Most loss assessors, including ICS, work on a percentage of the final settlement. This structure aligns our interests with yours—the better your settlement, the better for everyone. While fees typically range from 8-12% of the final settlement amount depending on claim complexity, our clients find that the increased settlement amount (averaging 30% higher according to the Professional Insurance Claims Association) more than covers our fees.
Why Choose ICS for Your Malicious Damage Claim
Insurance Claim Solutions is regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority and the Central Bank of Ireland, providing you with assurance of professional, ethical service. Our team combines expertise in insurance, construction, and negotiation.
With offices across Ireland in Dublin, Cork, Galway, and Limerick, we provide local service with national expertise. Our loss assessors come with decades of combined experience in claim management.
While ICS specializes in malicious damage claims, other reputable firms like Claims Management Group and Irish Claims Consultants also offer loss assessment services. We encourage you to research options and select a loss assessor registered with the Society of Claims Professionals (SOCP).
Take Action if You’ve Experienced Malicious Damage
If your home has been burgled or maliciously damaged, or if you intend to make a burglary claim, contact ICS today. Our initial consultation is free, allowing you to understand how we can help before making any commitment.
Don’t face the complexity of a malicious damage insurance claim alone. Let ICS handle the claim while you focus on restoring your property and peace of mind.
Insurance Claim Solutions: Your advocate against insurance companies when malicious damage strikes.